I have played melee CTF before, and it was cool, for awhile. Something different to do sometimes. In ChaosUT, we had SwordArena game type and mutator, SwordMelee mutator, and so forth. I remember scanning NC and places like that for tiny castle maps and stuff. Hehe, I had fun back then.
But I am not drawn towards Duel CTF. I'm just one who doesn't feel like it's a game of CTF until you have at least 6 players. 2 on 2 I can see if that's all you got, and if you pick the right maps, but 1 on 1 just doesnt' seem like it fits CTF. IMO anyway.
And I just can't see playing Chaos w/o a grapple. As Furry mentioned, we have a flag-drop-on-grapple option already, and from feedback I've been hearing over past weeks/months, I'd even be willing to make that the default setting. As much as I like grappling with the flag, I want human opponents even more.
But..., if we do that, then I would argue that we do not need to do anything else, like slowing down the flag carrier. The grapple is an excellent tool for moving about the maps, and if he's not able to use it, you should have a Fair and Balanced chance to catch him (unlike other new-fangled high-tech devices which have become so popular in today's tournaments). And I think that's true whether it's a melee match or not.
I realize you didn't exactly say this - but I think the important issue many folks "have wrong", IMO..., is that just because somebody has gotten your flag, does NOT mean you Have to get a shot at him, no matter where you were in the map at the time.
Some folks seem to think that if they can't catch the guy every time to get a crack at him, it's "unfair". Well, I'm not buying into that. Same as soccer, or basketball, football, or whatever. You need to be in position to make the play.
About the idea of using the flag as a weapon, well I just don't get it. I mean, either I've got some big gun, or I've got a big arsed blade of some sort, why would I want to pull some stick with a flag on it to hit you with? Not trying to be sarcastic here, but seriously? Doesn't it seem kinda silly given your other choices of weapons? Personally, I would like to see ChaosCTF strap the flag on the player's back, where it belongs, and leave it there.
But I'm all for matches of CTF using swords and axes and castles and flaming crossbows and grapples and catapults and flying cows...
..oh yeah